top of page

How to Prepare for a College Interview

Nov 9
12 min read
how to prepare for a college interview

At most highly selective schools, the college interview plays a small role in the admissions decision. Interviews are usually run by alumni volunteers who haven't read your application, and the report they write arrives after admissions officers have largely formed a view. MIT is the exception: it rates the interview “Important.” To prepare, treat it as a conversation, not a job interview. Know what your interviewer has to write about you (intellectual curiosity, commitment to your activities, character, and fit), have specific stories ready for each, reuse material from your essays since the interviewer hasn't seen them, and bring a few questions of your own. Send a thank-you email within 24 hours.

You submit your application and a few days later you get an email inviting you to interview. Two things happen. You get excited, because you think someone read your file and wants to meet you. And you get nervous, because you have no idea what to say.


Here's the truth. At Ivy Plus schools, the interview plays almost no role in the admissions decision. (MIT is the exception.) By the time an admissions officer reads the interview report, they've already read everything else in your file and pretty much made up their mind. They may glance at the report to confirm what they already believe. The interview is unlikely to make a difference.


I stress this because I don't want you to be nervous. Knowing the admissions decision isn't on the line, you can relax.


That doesn't mean the interview is entirely pointless. At selective schools, it's a chance to show demonstrated interest. It might tip a borderline decision. And in rare cases, a terrible interview (showing up late, being rude, making clear you've done zero research on the school) can hurt. Still, the range of outcomes is narrow.

 

Who Is Interviewing You (and Why That Matters)


One reason interviews carry limited weight is that they aren't conducted by admissions officers. They're conducted by alumni volunteers. These are people who loved their college experience enough to sign up, but they get a handbook, not formal training. They are given a document with areas to comment on and sometimes a rating scale to fill out. The admissions office knows this process is informal. It would be unfair for it to play a big part in decisions.


This is actually good news for you. Your interviewer isn't trying to catch you off guard or test you. They're a regular person trying to get a sense of who you are. Most of them genuinely enjoy learning about a smart teenager.

 

Don't Read Anything Into Getting (or Not Getting) an Interview


A lot of students get an interview invitation and think it means something. They assume someone in admissions read their application and was impressed enough to give an interview slot. Other students don't get an interview and worry something is wrong. Or they see a friend get one and feel like they fell behind.


Neither is true. Interview invitations often go out within days of submitting your application, sometimes so quickly that your file hasn't even been assembled in the admissions office. Nobody has looked at it. The office just wants to get the interview process moving.


What actually determines whether you get an interview is simple: is there an alumni volunteer available in your area? If there is, you'll probably get an invitation. If there isn't, you won't. Schools are clear about this. If you don't get an interview because no one was available, it won't count against you.

 

Think Conversation, Not Job Interview


The biggest mistake students make is treating the interview like an interrogation. They give short answers and wait for the next question. That's the wrong mindset.


A college interview is a conversation. The volunteers are there to get to know you. They ask open-ended questions and give you space to talk. It's common for a topic to come up and for the interview to just go down that path for ten minutes.


Since it's a conversation, it should go both ways. The interviewer will ask questions, but you should ask some back. One of my biggest pieces of advice: be curious about the other person. Ask about their time in college, the good and the bad. What did they study? What do they do now? What surprised them about the school? People enjoy talking about their own experience, and when you show real interest, they leave with a better impression of you than if you'd spent the whole time reciting your resume.


Be ready with a few questions before you walk in.

 

What Your Interviewer Has to Write About You


You can't know exactly what an interviewer will ask. But you can know something more useful: what they need to write in their report after talking to you.


Every alumni interviewer submits a report to the admissions office. And the report has specific categories. If you understand those categories, you understand what the interview is really about, and you can see why certain questions keep coming up.


The categories vary slightly from school to school, but they all ask for the same kind of thing.


Dartmouth


Dartmouth asks interviewers to comment on three areas:


  1. Intellectual engagement and curiosity

  2. Commitment and personal motivation in activities

  3. Character


Then the interviewer gives an overall rating on a six-point scale, from “Outstanding” to “Not Recommended.” For context, Dartmouth's interviewer guidelines note that most applicants are in the top five percent of all high school students, so interviewers are asked to make distinctions among strong candidates.


Yale


Yale interviewers are expected to report on intellectual curiosity, openness to ideas, and concern for others.


Penn


Penn's template asks interviewers to answer three questions:


  1. What qualities would help this student be successful at Penn?

  2. Which academic and extracurricular topics were of greatest interest?

  3. In what ways do the student's interests align with opportunities at Penn?


Harvard


Harvard's alumni interviewers, as revealed in documents from the SFFA v. Harvard lawsuit, assign a “personal” score and an “overall” score. The criteria for the personal rating include things like humor, sensitivity, grit, leadership, integrity, helpfulness, and courage. The interviewer handbook reportedly asks alumni to consider whether they'd want to share a room or a meal with the applicant.


Carnegie Mellon


Carnegie Mellon asks interviewers to rate applicants on enthusiasm, self-confidence, and ability to communicate, each on a 1-4 scale.

Look at those categories across schools. They're asking the same thing in different words: Is this student interesting? Do they care about something? Can they talk about it? Would I want them on my campus?

 

That's what you're preparing for. Not trick questions. Not a performance. You're giving your interviewer enough material to write a good report.

 

What Your Interviewer Knows About You (Almost Nothing)


Here's something most students don't realize: your interviewer hasn't read your application. They don't know your GPA, your test scores, or your activities list. They haven't seen your essays. All they have is your name, your high school, and your contact information. This is intentional. Alumni interviewers aren't even supposed to ask about grades or scores. Their job is to get to know you as a person, not to review your file.


This matters for one practical reason. The essays you wrote, both your personal statement and your supplements for that school, are some of your best material for the interview. You spent weeks on those. You figured out what you wanted to say and how to say it. Don't assume your interviewer already knows any of it. If your personal essay was about how working in your family's restaurant shaped the way you think about community, that's a great thing to talk about. If your “why this school” supplement explained how a specific research lab connects to a project you did in high school, bring that up too. The work you already did on your application is preparation you've already done for the interview. Use it.

 

The Questions You Should Be Ready For


Considering what interviewers need to write about, here are the questions most likely to come up. They won't all be asked. But some will.


The Opener


“Tell me about yourself.”

This is where most students stumble. They either give a list of activities or freeze because the question is so open. The answer isn't complicated: say what you care about most and why. Not everything about yourself. Just the thing that matters most to you right now, and one or two experiences that show it in action. You're giving the interviewer a way into the conversation, not delivering a speech.


My advice is to use the same advice I give for personal essays. Start with a clear message: the one thing you want to be sure the interviewer knows about you. If you have that message in your personal essay, use it again here. Remember, the interviewer has not read your essays.


Questions About Your Intellectual Life


These feed the “intellectual engagement and curiosity” section of the report.


  • What's your favorite class, and why?

  • What do you want to study in college?

  • Tell me about a book that changed how you think about something.

  • What topic or question have you been thinking about lately?

  • What current event has caught your attention?


A strong answer here goes past the surface. “I like history” doesn't give the interviewer anything to write down. “I got obsessed with the fall of the Roman Republic after reading a book about Caesar, and now I keep seeing parallels to modern politics” does. The interviewer needs specifics.


Questions About Your Activities and Motivation


These feed the “commitment and personal motivation” section.


  • Tell me about an extracurricular activity that matters to you.

  • What have you done over the past few summers?

  • Tell me about a challenge you faced and how you handled it.


The key here: don't list activities. Pick one and go deep. Why did you start? What changed along the way? What's hard about it? What did you learn that surprised you? Depth beats breadth. An interviewer can write a full paragraph about a student who spent ten minutes talking about one thing they care about. They can't write much about a student who rattled off five activities in two minutes.


Questions About Character


These feed the “character” and “personal qualities” section.


  • What are your strengths?

  • What's a weakness?

  • What three words would you use to describe yourself?


For the weakness question: name a real one. Saying “I work too hard” fools no one. Say something honest and explain what you've done about it. “I tend to take on too many things and then struggle to finish all of them. Last year I dropped two clubs so I could actually commit to the ones that mattered” is a real answer.


Questions About Why This School


These feed the “fit” and “contribution” section of the report.


  • Why do you want to attend this college?

  • What would you contribute to this campus?

  • What activities or programs here are you excited about?


This is research, not flattery. “Your school has world-class faculty” is worthless. Any applicant can say that. Name specific programs, professors, courses, or opportunities that connect to something you actually care about. If you can't name anything specific, you haven't done enough research, and your interviewer will notice.

 

What Makes a Strong Answer vs. a Weak One


The difference is simple. A strong answer gives the interviewer something specific to write down. A weak one gives them nothing.


Compare these two responses to “Tell me about an activity that matters to you”:

Weak: “I'm in Model UN. I really enjoy it. I've been doing it since sophomore year and I'm now the secretary general. I've won a few awards.”

 

Strong: “I got into Model UN because I was obsessed with the Syrian refugee crisis and couldn't believe the UN wasn't doing more. That frustration is what kept me coming back. Junior year I pushed our club to simulate the actual Security Council debate on Syria, and researching the Russian and Chinese vetoes made me realize how much harder international cooperation is than I'd assumed. That was the first time I changed my mind about something I felt strongly about.”

 

The first answer is a resume line. The second answer gives the interviewer a paragraph for their report. It shows intellectual curiosity, personal motivation, and a specific moment of growth. That's three categories covered in one answer.

 

When the Interviewer Goes Off-Script


Not all interviewers are good at this. Some are warm and conversational. Some are stiff and read from a list. Some will go off in unexpected directions: “If you could have dinner with anyone in history, who would it be?” or “What's a problem your generation needs to solve?”


Don't panic. These aren't trick questions. They're attempts to see how you think when you don't have a prepared answer. The right move is to pause, think for a few seconds, and say something honest. There's no correct answer. There's only the difference between a thoughtful response and a blank stare.


If you're asked something you genuinely don't know, say so. “I don't know enough about that to give you a good answer” is perfectly fine. Pretending to know something you don't is worse.

 

Alumni Interviews vs. Admissions Officer Interviews


Most interviews at selective schools are conducted by alumni. But a few schools, notably Georgetown, use trained admissions staff or highly structured alumni committees. Georgetown is the only top-ten university that requires an interview for every applicant, and their interviewers go through a more formal process than what you'll encounter at most schools.


If your interview is with an admissions officer (this is more common for on-campus interviews), expect it to be a bit more structured and a bit more evaluative. The basics are the same: be specific, be honest, be curious. But know that the person across from you does this professionally and will notice preparation (or the lack of it) faster than a volunteer would.

 

The MIT Exception


MIT is the exception to what I said above about interviews not mattering.


Most Ivy Plus schools rate the interview as “Considered” in their Common Data Set, which is admissions-speak for “we glance at it.” MIT rates the interview as “Important,” the same category as GPA, essays, and test scores.


MIT doesn't use a loose pool of alumni volunteers. They run their interviews through a network of more than 3,500 alumni they call Educational Counselors. These interviewers get training and submit detailed written reports. If you're interviewing for MIT, it counts.


One MIT-specific detail worth knowing: MIT encourages students to bring something they've made or worked on to the interview. Past students have brought laptops to show websites they built, copies of articles they wrote, or engineering projects they worked on. It's not required, but it's a chance to show rather than just tell.


Questions Specific to MIT


The MIT question list overlaps with other schools, but a few areas get more emphasis:


  • What are you most passionate about, and what have you done about it?

  • Tell me about a project you've built, made, or created.

  • What's a problem you'd love to solve?

  • Why MIT specifically? What about it fits you?

  • What would you contribute to the MIT community?


MIT's Educational Counselors are trained not to ask about your grades or test scores. They already know you're academically qualified. What they're looking for is curiosity that goes beyond the classroom, and evidence that you've acted on it.

 

The Logistics


A few practical things that shouldn't be afterthoughts.


Scheduling. When your interviewer reaches out, respond quickly and be flexible about timing. They're a volunteer. Make it easy for them.


What to wear. Business casual is fine. You don't need a suit. You do need to look like you took this seriously. For a virtual interview, the same applies from the waist up, and make sure your background is clean and your lighting is decent.


The thank-you note. Send a short email within 24 hours. Reference something specific you talked about. “Thank you for your time” is forgettable. “Your story about the economics seminar that changed your major is exactly the kind of experience I'm looking for” is not.


Arrive early. For in-person interviews, get there 10-15 minutes ahead. Grab a table. Settle your nerves. Being late is the one unforced error that actually leaves a bad impression.


How important is a college interview for admissions?

At most selective schools, the interview plays a small role. Alumni interviewers are volunteers without formal training, and admissions officers have usually formed a view of your application before they read the interview report. The interview can reinforce a strong application or tip a borderline decision, but it rarely changes an outcome on its own. MIT is a notable exception: it rates the interview as “Important” and trains its interviewers.

Yes. Declining an interview signals low interest, and some schools track demonstrated interest as a factor in admissions. The downside of a nervous but honest interview is small. The downside of declining is larger.

Business casual. Clean, neat, and put-together. You don't need a suit, but you shouldn't look like you rolled out of bed. For virtual interviews, make sure your background is tidy and your face is well-lit.

Most alumni interviews run 30 to 45 minutes. Some stretch to an hour if the conversation is going well. On-campus admissions officer interviews tend to be 30 minutes and more structured.

Ask specific questions you couldn't answer with ten seconds on the school's website. Good options: What did you love most about your time there? What would you change? What surprised you? What's the culture like outside the classroom? Your questions show the interviewer that you're thinking seriously about whether this school is right for you, not just whether you can get in.

Rarely. A nervous or awkward interview almost never hurts you. What can hurt is being rude, showing up completely unprepared, or saying something that suggests you haven't thought about the school at all. These are the things that generate negative reports. But they're easy to avoid.

Don't list your activities. Instead, say what you care about most and why. Give a short version of your story: the thing that matters to you, how you got interested in it, and what you've done about it. Keep it to about a minute. You're opening a conversation, not delivering a monologue.


Christopher Hunt - College Essay Consultant.jpg

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Christopher Hunt

College Essay Coach · Former WSJ & Economist Journalist · Published Author

Chris has spent over a decade helping students craft authentic, effective college essays for highly selective universities. A Dartmouth graduate (magna cum laude) with degrees from LSE and a year at Stanford Law, he draws on his journalism and book-writing background to teach clarity, structure, and voice.

  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
bottom of page